Whitetail Club

Golf Course Review by: Bill Satterfield

Quick Facts

Designer:  Andy North and Roger Packard in 2002

Cost: Private Club with some outside play permitted via outings

Phone Number:  (208) 630-0211

Course Website:  Official Website - Visit Whitetail's official website by clicking on the link provided.

Directions:  Get here! - 501 West Lake Street, McCall, Idaho 83638

Photos:  See additional photos of Whitetail

Accolades:  Ranked 9th in Idaho on Golf Digest's 2011-12 Best in State list. Ranked 5th best public course in Idaho in 2012 by Golf Magazine and Golfweek.

Signature Hole:  18th - 468 Yard Par 4 - A dramatic finish awaits at Whitetail as the dogleg right signature hole features a tee shot over a pond, a stream framing the right side of the hole, and a green with plenty of protection.

What to Expect:  Whitetail is the kind of club that puts its biggest emphasis on member service, comfort, and conditioning. The course plays through the trees for about half the holes and in the open area with water hazards for the other half of the holes. The fairways and greens are in immaculate shape and a laser range finder is provided in the posh cart so that you can dial in your exact yardages all day.

By the Numbers:

Tees Par Yardage Rating Slope
Gold 72 7287 71.8 135
Blue 72 6711 68.8 123
White 72 6165 65.9 114
Red 72 5179 61.9 101


Individual Hole Analysis

Best Par 3: Interestingly, all of the par 3s at Whitetail play in the "open" areas outside of the trees with the best one-shotter being featured at the 16th hole. A creek comes tumbling in from the left of the green and crosses in front of the hole and empties into the large pond that must be carried with your tee shot.

16th Hole at Whitetail Club (201 Yard Par 3)
16th Hole at Whitetail Club (201 Yard Par 3)

Best Par 4:  While some will argue that the 17th and 18th are the best par fours at Whitetail, I like the 10th. When I think of Whitetail I think of mature evergreen trees and the 10th hole affords an elevated tee shot to a generous fairway that then plays uphill to a green located in an amphitheatre of pines. It is a classic feeling hole with a strong dogleg and a precise uphill approach.

10th Hole at Whitetail Club (448 Yard Par 4)
10th Hole at Whitetail Club (448 Yard Par 4)

Best Par 5:  The fourth hole comes barrelling out a chute of trees to a large fairway that features sprinkler heads with more numbers on them than most cell phones. Why? Because after Whitetail opened it was determined that an additional green should be added to the fourth hole to provide a heroic shot over the water. So on some days the hole will play just 478 yards, while other days you'll find the flag in the green beyond the water to the right and will play 70 yards longer. The approach to the shorter green on the left is no slouch with a creek crossing in front of the hole.

4th Hole at Whitetail Club (478/548 Yard Par 5)
4th Hole at Whitetail Club (478/548 Yard Par 5)

Birdie Time: The short dogleg right 8th hole affords an excellent chance to get birdie for virtually every player. If you can hit it REALLY high then you can tee it up and thump the ball over the dogleg and try to reach the green. Normal humans will simply layup to the large landing area straight ahead and have a wedge or less into the green.

8th Hole at Whitetail Club (310 Yard Par 4)
8th Hole at Whitetail Club (310 Yard Par 4)

Bogey Beware:  It is extremely rare that I put a par five down as the biggest bogey obstacle to hurdle at a course, but the 2nd hole at Whitetail is the exception. First off, my swing is hardly grooved by the time I get to the second hole of the day and secondly anytime you have to thread your driver through a narrow chute of trees it can cause trouble. This hole doglegs left and offers no chance of cutting the corner from the tee box. The hole opens up more the closer you get to the green, but the approach shot plays uphill and must navigate away from the bunker that crosses in front of the green.

2nd Hole at Whitetail Club (510 Yard Par 5)
2nd Hole at Whitetail Club (510 Yard Par 5)

Final Cut:    Grade B-

Flyover Tour: